Archive | November, 2012

Tags: , , , ,

Being a Better Geek: Helm

Posted on 26 November 2012 by VinnieAve

Helm:

I cannot tell you when I read Helm for the first time.  I can tell you that I have read it once a year since then and it has been quite a few years.  That in itself makes it so that it deserves a slot on Be a Better Geek.  It is by no means a classic. It is a novel of clashing themes.  A science fiction novel that does not really contain very much science fiction.  A romance that hold little romance, or at least little perfect romance.  I could go on but I am sure Vincenzo will tell you what the book is about.  Whatever else you can say about helm, I can tell you that it contains the perfect mix of elements to keep me coming back year after year. Everyone else is on their own.

 

Vincenzo’s Take

The basic premise behind this book is that the earth has been essentially destroyed due to a nuclear war that was started because of mind-control or something and now a small group of scientists are sending off some colonists with instructions imprinted in their mind (or at least some colonists get imprinted) for how to run a society, essential be literate, clean, and eat well are the plan. This seems like it could be a neat book, and that is just the prologue.

Then we jump forward a few hundred years to one of these colonies. Leland de Laal (terrible name, anime level bad) gets imprinted when he climbs a mountain where the device is kept (the titular helm) and gets all sorts of crazy knowledge about lost languages like German and martial arts skills as well as other stuff that the novel hasn’t covered too much.

Because Leland puts on the helm his father punishes him because this is forbidden and is sent off and learns aikido (which has survived for some reason). This is where my first issue arises in full force. There had been a large us of Japanese words earlier in the book with the translation next to them, I had assumed that when this was with the scientists that it was to give diversity to the group. However, this is a constant problem in the book, sensei and kohai (among other words) can be easily translated and it comes off as this author showing off his knowledge of aikido which just annoys me hear like it does when I see it in translations of anime and manga.

Leland returns and is sent off again to fight in the annual war with the neighboring nation (this seems like a bit of a contrivance). He had already fallen in love with some noble daughter passing through and he stays in the capital while they prepare for war. Here, like in good old Game of Thrones we have to deal with nebbish young boy having sexual feelings, everyone knows this is my favorite thing to read, good god!

There are plenty of elements that I like in this, like stories about nobility and generals and court intrigue, information about troop size and training regiment, a post-apocalyptic setting and plan to save civilization, I love all of these thing then why is it that I this novel isn’t doing anything for me other than causing me brief bits of intense anger. I have to think that it is because our main character is pretty dull. It doesn’t seem to have any flaws and always does the right thing. There haven’t been any big challenges thrown at him thus far. Also while there are elements that I like they aren’t done particularly well, his main rival and the villain of the whole book just seems mustache twirling. This also applies to his father who is more evil and more mustache twirling.

The second half does follow-up and build on what happened in this story. Sadly it did little to change my perception of the book. I wish recommend this book but with a near total lack of character. I never felt that the character could fail at his task which is an important element for me. The sad part is that Leland really has no major flaws that impede his success.

I find that difficult especially where there is a great world for those characters to exist. I would actually like to see more of this world but probably more as a role-playing game source book than another novel.

The next Being a Better Geek is a bit of stretch since I’m going with 3 movies connected by a theme. The theme is World’s Best. For this we will be looking at Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro, Golgo 13: The Professional, and Black Jack the Movie.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Cycle of the Werewolf, Powerpuff Girls, Halloween and Scream

Posted on 19 November 2012 by VinnieAve

Comments (2)

Escaflowne Final Thoughts

Posted on 12 November 2012 by VinnieAve

DM’s Final Thoughts

Of all the animated series I have been exposed to since we have started Be a Better Geek, Escaflowne is hands down my favorite.  That is not to say that it is my favorite show ever by any means. It has its flaws after all.  This is a strong show though, and for the first time I can say that I plan on re-watching this at some point.

Escaflowne’s strength was in its ability to bring you genuine characters who, for the most part, responded in ways that were not outrageous.  Hitome was any other teenage girl who found herself lost in a distant place whilst discovering she was developing strange new abilities.

I was very impressed with the production value as well.  I was impressed with the animation and most especially the sound.  It felt closer to a low budget feature than a television show.

All in all I had no major complaints.  The plot was a bit predictable and the melodrama made me feel like I was watching a fantasy soap opera. Perhaps it these aspects were necessary to create the show though.

 

Vincenzo’s Final Thoughts

I picked this show mainly because I wanted to do a fantasy not sci-fi like the vast majority of things we’ve done have been. This allowed some other elements to come into play as well, particularly shojo elements, in this case having a strong-ish female main character, “pretty boy” character designs, that are present here that have not been present in other places and as well giant robots are just plain cool.

This show manages to pack a lot of material into a fairly small amount of time. Normally, this might lead to a rushed and busy feeling but it does little to no detriment to the show overall. My actual fear is that if this series had been much longer it might have started to drag in parts, which it never did, a rare feat for a mecha-show.

Since most of these thoughts deal with the second half of the show there is that patented anime second half effect wherein the show gets significantly darker in the second half often as a result of the mid-season battle. Here we see many of the characters we knew change and have major revelations about their past. The show does a good job of setting up a situation and having a satisfying pay-off later on. I don’t want to spoil the ending but unlike many shows the I didn’t feel particularly let down with what happened. The ending also sort of made sense. I say sort of, since it was pretty weird, it wasn’t a normal battle but major events did happen.

At the end of the day, I forgot how much I loved this show. There is a reason that this succeeded to have a movie made later on (I’m not commenting on this). Everything about this show is something I want to see more about, I want to see interesting mecha shows, I want shows that have fantastic music, I want there to be decent characters.

Comments (0)

Advertise Here
Advertise Here

RSS Feeds

All Posts Feed

Podcast Feed

Now available on Stitcher Radio!

All Geeks Considered Facebook

Buy us a Coffee